Dennis Eckersley built a Hall of Fame career on the mound, yet September 7, 1985 delivered a rare batting milestone. The Chicago right-hander took the ball against Cincinnati and quickly fell behind when Eddie Milner launched a leadoff homer. Chicago answered in the bottom of the first to tie the score at 1-1. An inning later, Eckersley grabbed a bat and created a memorable chapter in his career.
With two outs and the bases empty in the bottom of the second, Eckersley stepped in against rookie left-hander Tom Browning. His first nine major league seasons came in the American League under the designated hitter rule. He entered this contest in his second National League campaign with just 10 hits, all singles, in 98 career at-bats. That history offered little hint of what came next.
To the shock of all in attendance, Eckersley hammered a solo homer over the fence and gave the Cubs a 2-1 lead. The blast marked both the first extra-base hit and the first home run of his major league career. For a pitcher who finished with only three career homers, the swing represented a notable milestone.
Eckersley returned to the mound and protected the lead until the fourth inning. Then Hall of Famer Dave Parker struck back with a game-tying home run. After completing the frame, Eckersley departed with the score even at 2-2. His final line showed four innings, four hits, two earned runs, two strikeouts, and no walks. He left without a decision, but the afternoon still had plenty of drama remaining.
Browning worked through six innings and exited with the score tied 3-3. Chicago then exploded for six runs in the seventh and seized a commanding 9-3 advantage. The lead stood until the ninth when manager Jim Frey summoned reliever Lee Smith out of the ‘pen. The Cooperstown closer allowed two singles, recorded two outs, and walked Pete Rose to load the bases. Parker followed with a grand slam that cut the margin to 9-7. With the tying run on deck, Smith retired Nick Esasky on a grounder to second and ended the threat.
Eckersley never factored into the decision, yet he still authored the day’s most memorable moment. Shown here is a ticket from that contest, signed by Eckersley with the fitting inscription, “1st MLB HR”.