Before David Wright arrived, the Mets rarely used a captaincy as a steady symbol. The franchise first named Keith Hernandez captain immediatley following their 1986 championship season. He brought grit and command to the clubhouse. Gary Carter joined him as co-captain in 1988 and shared leadership duties through 1989.
The Mets then entered a long stretch without a captaincy. John Franco finally revived the title in 2001 and held it through 2004, bringing veteran stability to a changing roster.
Wright stepped into that lineage on March 21, 2013. The Mets named him the fourth captain in franchise history. He carried that responsibility until 2018. Wright led with quiet consistency and earned admiration as one of the most respected figures in team history.
The artifact shown here tells a different story from inside the scouting world. An advance scout once evaluated Gary Carter, the Mets’ second captain, with blunt notes. Advance scouts prepare reports on the opponents the team is next facing. This report from May 21, 1987, offers an unvarnished snapshot.
The scout wrote, “Not hitting real well.” He also labeled Carter’s arm, “Avg – not throwing well.” The words feel small next to a Hall of Fame résumé.
Carter did not ignore the slight. He signed the report and added a pointed message above his autograph. He wrote, “Don’t always believe the scouting report.” That line turned criticism into a reminder that one page never tells the full story of a career.