In 2005, the Hall of Fame put together a special screening committee. Their charge was to find people associated with the Negro Leagues who were most deserving of induction.
An original list of 94 nominees was cut to 29 candidates and finally 17 new members of the Hall of Fame to be inducted. in 2006. The cover of the 2006 Hall of Fame yearbook shows those 17 and including Jud Wilson.
His Hall of Fame plaque reads, “A hard-nosed fiery competitor, who excelled in three decades as a first baseman with the Baltimore Black Sox, Homestead Grays, and Philadelphia Stars. Feared and respected batter who terrorized pitchers by hitting over .350, including several seasons over .400. Captained renowned 1931 Homestead Grays and played on four championship teams. Named to three East-West All Star teams and starred in the Cuban Winter League.”