The last men to throw 20 innings in a single game did it against each other. On May 24, 1929 the Tigers squared off against the White Sox at Chicago’s Comiskey Park. Detroit sent George Uhle; Chicago countered with future Cooperstown man Ted Lyons.
The game lasted 21 innings with Uhle going all but three outs and Lyons lasting the distance.
Both pitchers were less than sharp to start. Uhle gave up five runs on ten hits through the first five innings. Lyons wasn’t much better, allowing his fifth run and 11th hit in his 6th frame.
From there the two right-handers put up zero after zero after zero. After 9 innings the game was tied at five. Another 9 innings later, the score remained the same.
The game entered the 21st inning with Uhle at bat. He reached on an infield single, his fourth hit of the game. His night ended when he was lifted for pinch runner Emil Yde.
Uhle departed after 20 innings. He gave up 5 runs on 17 hits and 3 walks. He struck out 4. In a game with 164 plate appearances, no batter for either team had more hits than Uhle.
Charlie Gehringer put Uhle in line for the win three batters later with a sacrifice fly. Iron man Lyons retired the next batter to end the visitor’s half of the 21st inning.
The game’s first reliever Lil Stoner recorded the final three outs to end the contest.
Lyons took the loss after throwing all 21 innings. He allowed 6 runs on 24 hits while walking 2 striking out 4. The game marked the last time any hurler completed at least 20 innings in a single game.
In the collection is this letter from AL president William Harridge dated January 6, 1959. He writes to Hall of Fame pitcher Lyons, thanking the 21-year AL veteran for his well wishes.
He writes, “I have enjoyed my long association with baseball and many of the nice friends I have made among the players, which, of course, includes Teddy Lyons. In your playing days you always gave a good account of yourself on the ball field, and since your retirement since active duty you have carried on for the good of our National Game.”