Larry Gardner played on the winning side in four World Series. The deciding moment of his first in 1912 came in Game 8. It was Gardner who became the unlikely hero with the first walk-off in Fall Classic history.
The October matchup pitted the New York Giants against Gardner’s Red Sox. With a Game 2 tie and three wins apiece, the decider came in October 16th’s Game 8. After 9 innings the contest was tied. The 10th became one of the most famous frames in Fall Classic history.
It happened because of a defensive gaffe by Fred Snodgrass. A versatile defender, Snodgrass played every position but pitcher though the majority of his games were in centerfield. It is there that a singular play defined his baseball legacy.
In the bottom of the 10th inning with his Giants clinging to a 2-1 lead, Snodgrass dropped a routine fly ball off the bat of Clyde Engel for a two-base error. Harry Hooper then scorched a long drive that Snodgrass snagged with a spectacular catch in deep center.
The next batter Steve Yerkes walked before Tris Speaker singled to score Engel and send Yerkes to third. The game was now tied.
Giants pitcher Christy Mathewson issued an intentional pass to Duffy Lewis to load the bases and bring up third baseman Gardner. With a sacrifice fly to right, Gardner became the hero and sealed Snodgrass’s fate as the goat.
Gardner’s ability to perform under pressure marked his career and contributed to two more Boston titles in 1915 and 1916. Gardner’s decade with the Red Sox earned him a spot in the team’s Hall of Fame in 2000.
The collection includes a letter penned and signed by World Series goat Fred Snodgrass. Dated November 5, 1955, the letter references the Dodgers’ Fall Classic victory— their only championship representing Brooklyn.
Snodgrass writes, “Was happy the ‘Bums’ won this year at last. I had lunch this spring with them at Vero Beach. 400 players in uniform was quite a sight.”
After retiring in 1916, Snodgrass returned to California, where he became a successful businessman, City Councilman, and Mayor of Oxnard. He enjoyed renewed fame with the 1963 release of Larry Ritter’s book The Glory of Their Times. Fred Snodgrass passed away in Ventura, California, in 1974 at age 86.