Why doesn’t Kevin Brown get more love?
When mentioning the great pitchers of his era, Brown’s name is rarely brought up.
It should be.
The 6’4″ hurler had five top-six finishes in Cy Young balloting, led the league in wins once, ERA twice, and WHIP twice. When it comes to WAR, Brown topped his circuit’s pitchers twice, finished second once, and third twice. His 68.2 career WAR ranks 36th among all pitchers in the game’s history.
Strong and durable, Brown made 25 or more starts in 13 seasons, leading the league in the category three times. Only 66 pitchers in baseball history started more games in their careers. Though he never led the league in complete games, Brown finished in the league’s top-5 in the category six times and in the top-10 nine times overall.
During a dominant five-year peak from 1996-2000, Brown was the National League’s finest pitcher. Each season he was in the Senior Circuit’s top-3 in WAR. An All Star in four of those five seasons, Brown averaged more than 210 strikeouts and 240 innings per year.
The leader in ERA, ERA+, shutouts, WHIP, and pitchers’ WAR in 1996, Brown finished second in the Cy Young race. The following year his 2.69 mark was bested by only four NL hurlers. His 16 wins and 205 strikeouts helped the Marlins win in all in ’97.
In 1998, Brown put up a career-best 8.9 WAR while leading the league in starts and finishing second in ERA and innings pitched. The ’99 campaign was more of the same. His second-straight 18-win season featured his 3rd consecutive season with at least 200 Ks.
The first year of the new millennium Brown had the NL’s lowest ERA (2.58) and WHIP (0.991). He also posted his 4th-straight 200-strikeout finish.
During the magnificent 5-year run, Brown’s 2.51 ERA and 36.7 WAR were bested only by Hall of Fame hurler Pedro Martinez. That’s in all of baseball.
Working against Brown’s case for Cooperstown is his lack of a gaudy career milestone. While his 211 wins and 2,397 strikeouts are impressive, they simply aren’t magical numbers that Hall voters like. Perhaps the biggest blow to Brown’s Hall chances came in 2007 when he was implicated for the use of performance-enhancing drugs in the Mitchell Report.
Brown became eligible for Cooperstown in 2011. Just 2.1% of the writers named him on their ballots. The poor showing despite his career statistics and dominance point to the writers’ resentment of his likely PED use.
As memory of the Steroid Era fades, players suspected of drug use continue to gain induction to the Hall of Fame. If the pattern continues to hold, Brown may one day get a plaque via the Veterans Committee.
In the collection is this Kevin Brown autographed Strat-O-Matic card from 1996. Bucknell University math major Hal Richman originated the Strat-O-Matic game in 1961. Advertised in Sports Illustrated and sold out of Richman’s basement, Strat-O-Matic gave its players the ability to make managerial decisions based on MLB statistics.