Johnny Mize enjoyed a 15-year career in the big leagues. His production was so great that he made the Hall of Fame despite missing three full seasons in his prime due to World War II.
Mize broke in with the Cardinals in 1936 and made an immediate impact. The 23-year old played in 126 games, hit .329 with a .402 on-base percentage and a .577 slugging mark. His 19 homers led the club while his 93 RBI were second only to Hall of Famer Joe Medwick.
Mize received MVP votes in 5 of his 6 years with the Cardinals. In 1939, he hit .349 to capture the batting crown. Mize followed up that campaign by posting an NL-best 43 homers and 137 RBI. In both ’39 and ’40 he finished as runner up in the MVP race. His 6 seasons in St. Louis featured an OPS of 1.018.
Despite his performance in 1940, Cardinals owner Sam Breadon offered only a slight raise in pay. Mize held out for more money before signing in March of 1941.
The relationship between Mize and the Cardinals was forever damaged. In December of ’41 St. Louis GM Branch Rickey dealt Mize to the New York Giants for pitcher Bill Lohrman, catcher Ken O’Dea, first baseman Johnny McCarthy and $50,000. It remains one of the worst trades in Cardinals history.
Mize continued his greatness in New York, leading the NL in RBI and slugging percentage in his first year with the Giants. World War II then interrupted his dominance as Mize missed three years, starting in his age-30 season.
Upon his return, Mize didn’t miss a beat. In 1946 he slashed .337/.437/.536. In ’47 he led the league in runs and RBI and tied for the top spot in homers. His 51 bombs came with only 42 strikeouts.
Though the slugger again tied for the league lead in homers in ’48, his averaged dipped below .300 for the first time in his career. Through the first 106 games of 1948 Mize hit .263. This marked the end of his regular-season dominance.
In the collection is this contract signed by Mize on St. Patrick’s Day, 1948. The deal calls for Mize’s stamped signature to appear on souvenir baseballs. The terms of the contract? Mize received one cent per ball sold.
He was overlooked for too many years. HOFer for sure.