Elmer Flick played big league baseball before the turn of the century, debuting in 1898. His father, Zachary Flick was a veteran of the American Civil War.
During his 13-year MLB career, Flick led the league in batting average, RBI, and runs scored once each, stolen bases twice, and triples three times, Flick compiled a .313 lifetime average, a .389 on-base percentage and a 148 OPS+.
In the collection is this signed photo that shows Flick and a caption that reads, “Elmer Flick in 1906 was valued more highly than Ty Cobb.”
Cobb was just 20 years old and had yet to hit his stride. The 1905 batting champ, Flick was ten years Cobb’s senior and coming off an ’06 campaign in which he tallied 194 hits and 34 doubles while leading the league in runs, triples, and steals.
Before the start of the ’07 season, Tigers manager Hughie Jennings called Indians owner Charles Somers offering Cobb for Flick. Somers turned down the offer because of his respect for Flick as a person and player. Flick never really gained the stardom that Cleveland management hoped for though he did win the American League batting crown in 1905.
Sometimes the best trades are the ones that never happen. Just ask the Detroit Tigers.
Interestingly, when Cobb died in 1961, the story of the possible trade of The Georgia Peach for Flick reemerged. The renewed interest in Flick’s career ultimately resulted in his unanimous election to the Hall of Fame by the Veterans Committee, 65 years after his MLB debut in 1898.