Based on his baseball accomplishments, Charles Finley warrants a plaque in Cooperstown. As team owner he controlled everything concerning his team. His guidance led the A’s to back-to-back-to-back World Series titles. The New York Yankees are the only other franchise to accomplish the feat.
So what’s keeping Finley out of the Hall of Fame?
According to his SABR biography, “Nearly everyone, including fellow owners, players, the fans of his teams, the media, and the baseball commissioner, disliked or even despised him.”
When his team lost, he blamed everyone but himself. When they won, he was apt to call the radio booth during the game if his name was not mentioned often enough. He was a self-made millionaire who, in the words of sportswriter Jim Murray, “worshipped his creator.”
In the collection is the first of two handwritten letter in which Dick Williams opines about Athletics owner Charlie Finley. Williams writes, “I was the first manager he had to go longer than one year with him — I managed three years and won division championships all three years plus two World Series Championships. Three years was long enough!”.