Carl Erskine’s finest season came in 1953. That year he set career highs in wins, strikeouts, and WAR. The 20-game winner pitched the Brooklyn Dodgers into that season’s Fall Classic. In Game 3 against the Yankees, Erskine fanned 14 New York batters to break Howard Ehmke’s mark of 13 K’s established in Game 1 of the ’29 Series.
In the collection is this letter dated January 11, 1954, just three months after pitching his October gem. Erskine writes to 1929 batting champ Lew Fonseca, who by then was MLB’s Director of Promotions , “I received the 1953 World Series film and have all ready (sic) enjoyed seeing it several times. I always get he feeling early in the film that this is the year were (sic) going to do it but it always comes out the same.
“Because of its contents, I treasure this as the top memento of my professional baseball career…”
Though his signature is common, letters signed by Erskine from the 1950s are seldom seen. The content of this example makes the letter highly desirable.