Brett Saberhagen’s Cooperstown resumé is headlined by two Cy Youngs and a World Series MVP award. His 58.9 career WAR fits in nicely among pitchers inducted into the Hall of Fame. The total stands above no-doubt inductees such as Three-Finger Brown, Mariano Rivera, Whitey Ford and Sandy Koufax.
Sabes’ career is an interesting one when broken down by odd-numbered and even-numbered years.
In 1985 he won 20 games, the Cy Young and World Series MVP Award. In ’87 the right-hander was an All Star and 18-game winner. Two years later in ’89, his league-leading 23 wins, 2.16 ERA, and 12 complete games earned him a second Cy Young Award. Saberhagen’s WAR totals in those three campaigns were impressive: 7.1 in ’85, 8.0 in ’87, and 9.7 in ’89. For good measure, he pitched a no-hitter in another odd-numbered year – 1991. Together, all that sounds like a Hall of Famer.
The problem is his ineffectiveness in the intervening even-numbered seasons. In 1984, ’86, ’88, ’90, and ’92 he went a combined 39-53 with losing records each season.
Another knock on Saberhagen’s career is that his greatness was too brief. After coming out of the gate with 92 wins by the end of his age-25 season, Saberhagen won just 85 contests the rest of his career. From 1995 until he retired in 2001, the right-hander earned only 33 victories.
When he hung up his spikes, Saberhagen’s win total stood at 167, far below the 200-victory mark preferred by the voters. His 3.34 career ERA and 1,715 strikeouts don’t feel like Hall of Fame numbers.
When it came time for Hall of Fame voting, Saberhagen’s early-career, odd-numbered-year dominance simply wasn’t long enough for the baseball writers. After receiving 1.7% of the vote in his first year of eligibility, Saberhagen was one-and-done on their ballot.
His candidacy now lies in the hands of the Veterans Committee.
In the collection is this document signed by Saberhagen on July 14, 1998. That day Sabes took the mound against the Tampa Bay Devil Rays at Tropicana Field. Pitching for the Red Sox, he allowed 4 runs on 7 hits through 5 1/3 innings in a no-decision. For the season Saberhagen tossed 175 innings, going 15-8 with 100 strikeouts for the 92-win Boston club.