Perhaps the greatest rivalry in all of baseball is between the New York Yankees and the Boston Red Sox. From 1969-1978 Bill Lee played in Beantown and saw it up close.
On May 20, 1976 the two rivals squared off at Yankee Stadium. New York led 1-0 heading into the bottom of the 6th inning. With two out, Lou Piniella and Graig Nettles reached base with back-to-back singles.
Otto Velez smoked a line drive base hit to right field fielded. Third base coach Dick Howser waved Piniella home. Boston right fielder Dwight Evans came up with the ball and threw a laser to catcher Carlton Fisk. Piniella crashed into the Boston backstop who tagged him out.
Chaos ensued.
Nettle’s describes the action: “It started with a collision at home plate with Piniella and Fisk and they came up fighting. The year before we’d had a fight in Boston and Bill Lee said the Yankees fought like Times Square hookers. I just wanted to let him know we had some tough hookers in Times Square.
“He was in on the pile and I saw him taking swings at people. I threw him on the ground and he told me he’d get me next time.
“I said, ‘Let’s not wait ’till next time, let’s do it now.’
“So I popped him in the eye a couple of times. I remember some of their players coming up to me the next day congratulating me so they wouldn’t have to put up with that guy.”
Lee suffered a dislocated shoulder and a bruised ego. He didn’t pitch again until July 15th. On July 23rd he faced the Yankees for the first time since the brawl. Nettles went 2-for-4, including a two-run homer off of Lee as the Boston left-hander gave up 7 earned runs in four innings of work.
Shown here is a Yankee payroll check issued to Nettles on August 15, 1973. For more on Nettles, click here to access his page.