Born in 1890, Bill Jacobson was a hulking man for his day. Standing at 6’3″ and weighing in at 215 pounds during his playing career, he also had one of baseball’s unlikeliest nicknames – “Baby Doll”.
Jacobson got tagged with the moniker in 1912. The 21-year old Jacobson was entering his third year of professional baseball, playing for the Class-A Mobile Sea Gulls. According to his SABR bio, Jacobson received the nickname in the home opener.
“Everybody called me Bill until that day in Mobile. It was opening day and a band was playing. Just before the first pitch, they struck up ‘Oh, You Beautiful Doll,’ a popular song at the time. Well, I led off with a homer on the first pitch and a lady sitting behind the plate jumped up and shouted: ‘You must be that beautiful doll they were talking about.’ The name stuck with me and that was it.”
Baby Doll reached the big leagues with the Tigers in 1915. A centerfielder by trade, Jacobson’s playing time in Detroit was limited with Ty Cobb in front of him. In August the Tigers traded him to the St. Louis Browns.
A slow start and his service in World War I kept Jacobson from hitting his stride until 1919. That season he was flanked in the St. Louis outfield by Ken Williams in left and Jack Tobin in right. The trio went on to start 556 contests together, the most by any outfield in baseball history.
Jacobson hit .323 in 1919 to start a run of 7 consecutive seasons of .300 or better. In ’20 Baby Doll had his finest season, hitting .355 with a .402 on-base percentage and a .501 slugging mark. His 122 runs batted in was topped only by Babe Ruth.
During the height of his career, Jacobson was one of the game’s most productive players. From 1919-1926, only Hall of Famers Sam Rice (1,639), Rogers Hornsby (1,626), Harry Heilmann (1,556), George Sisler (1,495), and Cobb (1,478), had more hits than Baby Doll (1,473).
Exceptionally agile for his size, he was considered one of the game’s finest defensive centerfielders. Each season from 1919-1925 he placed in the top 5 among AL flycatchers in putouts, leading the league three times.
Jacobson set or tied more than a dozen defensive records. His 488 putouts in 1924 stood as the American League mark until after the second World War.
In 1926 the Browns traded him to the Red Sox in a four-player deal. The following season he split time in Boston, Cleveland, and Philadelphia before ending his big league career. Jacobson’s lifetime average stands at .311. As of 2022 only 100 men in the history of the game have a higher tally.
Baby Doll continued playing in the minors and in a semipro league past his 40th birthday. After leaving the game for good, he became purchased a farm in Illinois not far from where he was born.
In the collection is this index card signed by Bill “Baby Doll” Jacobson.