Baseball provides the exception for the adage, “Nobody’s perfect”. Twenty-four pitchers have authored perfection in single-game performances where they retired all 27 batters in a row. Umpire Ted Barrett holds the distinciton as the only man to call balls and strikes in two of them.
Barrett first worked the plate in a perfecto mastered by David Cone in 1999. Thirteen years later, on June 13, 2012, he returned to that rare stage. This time, Matt Cain forged perfection against Houston.
Cain owned every inch of the strike zone that night. He fired 125 pitches and struck out 14 hitters. That total matched Sandy Koufax for the most in a perfect game. Houston never solved his rhythm, his command, or his nerve.
The game hinged on one breathtaking moment in the seventh. Jordan Schafer drove a full-count pitch deep into the right-center gap. Gregor Blanco tracked it stride for stride. He lunged near the warning track and stretched to his limit. Blanco secured the ball as he slid, then rose and flashed his glove. Cain threw his arms up, grateful and fired up.
The final out came quietly but carried thunder. Cain retired Jason Castro, sealing history. Buster Posey sprinted to the mound and wrapped him up. Teammates swarmed, and the park erupted.
In an article on the Hall of Fame’s website, Barrett explained his mindset in the pair of perfect games he called.
“If you think of those situations, everything’s magnified. So that is what the pressure is. As a plate umpire, you established your strike zone, and you tried to be consistent. And now you have to not just be consistent, but you have to be accurate. And in that perfect game situation, you had to be accurate because if it was a 3-and-2 pitch that should have been a ball that I called strike three, well, everybody would say, ‘Look, he got a perfect game and he didn’t deserve it.’ Or if it was strike three and it’s ball four, you know, he cost him the perfect game.
“You’re not worried about the fame, you’re just worried about getting the call right. There’s pressure on the umpire. I feel like I caught lightning in a bottle twice being able to stand behind the plate and be a part of a perfect game.”
Shown here, a ticket from that night bears Barrett’s signature and a simple note. It marks the performance with Barrett’s inscription, “HP umpire#65 Matt Cain Perfect Game”.
Barrett added another chapter that same season. He umpired third base for Philip Humber on April 21, 2012. Humber delivered his own perfect game, and Barrett stood nearby, watching history unfold from a different angle.